| 1 | Hosey, Andre | Wayland Baptist | 1:57.35 | | 55.23 | 1:57.35 | | (55.23) | (1:02.13) |
|
| 2 | Woodberry, Cameron | Wayland Baptist | 2:00.04 | | 57.23 | 2:00.04 | | (57.23) | (1:02.81) |
|
| 3 | Black, Rashaun | Odessa | 2:00.51 | | 57.04 | 2:00.51 | | (57.04) | (1:03.47) |
|
| 4 | Dominguez, Matt | Eastern New Mexico | 2:00.86 | | 56.94 | 2:00.86 | | (56.94) | (1:03.93) |
|
| 5 | Bindues, Johnathon | Unattached | 2:04.05 | | 55.94 | 2:04.05 | | (55.94) | (1:08.11) |
|
| 6 | Dotaona, Richard | Papua New Guinea Track | 2:07.97 | | 58.75 | 2:07.97 | | (58.75) | (1:09.23) |
|
| 7 | Lozano, Casey | Eastern New Mexico | 2:12.16 | | 1:01.32 | 2:12.16 | | (1:01.32) | (1:10.84) |
|
| 8 | Davila, Antonio | Western Texas College | 2:17.70 | | 1:03.45 | 2:17.70 | | (1:03.45) | (1:14.26) |
|
| 9 | Garnsey, Don | Odessa | 2:23.54 | | 1:06.82 | 2:23.54 | | (1:06.82) | (1:16.72) |
|
| Dunn, Kevin | Wayland Baptist | DNF | |
| McMath, Skylar | Eastern New Mexico | DNS | |
| Lopez, Ulisses | Wayland Baptist | DNF | |
| Canales, Carlos | Western Texas College | DNS | |
